There are so many myths and misconceptions about what a private investigator can do. Different states have different laws. What is legal in state A may be illegal in state B. There is so much that a private investigator can’t do that people think they can.
One of the commonly asked private investigator legal questions is whether they are allowed to record conversations. The answer to this may be a YES or NO, depending on some factors.
The law takes video and audio recording very differently. Keep reading to get a clear understanding of whether it is legal for a private investigator to record conversations.
Everyone is allowed by the law to record videos and take pictures of another person, but only in public places where the victim doesn’t expect privacy. Recording a video in bathrooms, washrooms, bedrooms, and changing rooms is illegal.
For instance an Australian investigators can record videos in any place where the victim doesn’t expect privacy. PIs aren’t legally allowed to record videos in your home until there is a consent.
What if your partner (wife or husband) records you? Is that legal? The answer is YES if he or she notifies you in advance.
Installing surveillance cameras in homes is allowed, but not in private rooms. For the safety of your baby, you can install surveillance cameras without having to inform your nanny. When installing surveillance cameras in your home, don’t do it secretly.
When it comes to audio recording, the laws are much more restrictive and complicated. Audio recording falls into two categories depending on the state you’re. There are one-party consent states and all-party consent states.
To record audio in one-party consent state, one or both parties involved in the conversation needs to consent to the recording. A private investigator is legally allowed to record conversations only when one party or person involved in the conversation consents to the recording.
To record a conversation in all-party consent states, all parties involved in the conversation needs to consent to the recording.
Consents are different from notifications. Notifying those involved in the conversation is not enough. You may lack evidence when asked to provide in court. It is advisable to have to consent in the recording. Before a private investigator starts recording, he or she must inform all parties involved in the conversation.
Cell phone tapping
Recording phone calls and cell phone tapping also falls in this category. In one-party consent states, a private investigator can secretly record conversations with permission from one party involved.
In all-party consent states, recording phone conversations is legal only if both parties are aware. Even if you’re using your smartphone’s in-built recording features, make sure to inform your partner.
Law isn’t like mathematics where absolute answers can be derived, in law, there is room for reasoning. Different judges can rule the same case differently. Under some circumstances, recording without informing both parties in all-party states is acceptable. You can record someone who is threatening your life without his knowledge.